Excellent service and food. - 3/31/2024 

Love it !!! - 1/25/2024 

We love this place. The staff is awesome. Omni and Nestor are incredible. We visit about 2-3 times per month. We love the little bar. Comfy. Quaint. - 1/21/2024 

Best margaritas south of Indy! Food and service is 5☆! - 1/18/2024 

Awesome Food,Drinks and Service - 12/17/2023 

Greatest hidden gem in Bargersville. Great food, staff & Margheritas! - 12/14/2023 

Best Mexican place around. I love coming here. - 12/08/2023 

This place has amazing food! Staff is great Nester is the best server! Fun place family friendly. Reasonable prices great taco Tuesday specials! - 11/16/2023 

Food and service were great. Hit the spot for the whole family after a day of games. - 11/11/2023 

Went there for lunch twice. Great wait staff. Food was terrific - 11/05/2023 

I'm not huge on Mexican food. But this place is hands down my favorite. Tried a few different things at this point. Everything is awesome. Highly recommend Parking: Parking lot isn't the greatest - 11/03/2023 

Really great margaritas - 10/17/2023 

We ordered the burritos fajitas and there was no flavor in the meat. We left over half of the burritos. The margaritas, salsa, and service was great though. - 8/20/2023 

Don't know what the difference is with the salsa. But it as well as everything we tried was very good. Nothing fancy, just delicious. - 8/20/2023 

Waitress didn't have a good vibe but hey it went OK and did was ok - 8/04/2023 

Beautiful wood carved seats and paintings - 7/19/2023 

Went for lunch it honestly was great ...secret item menu is birria they sell it I had them put it in a burrito and it turned out great 👍 I'll post pics as well the service was great the pictures are of my birria burrito. Kids Arroz con Carne rice and beans as well they were the rice was phenomenal beans were terrific too Street tacos were fantastic as well im not disappointed in anything here but for a 5 star review from me it has to be like life changing the go to spot so they are terrific no complaints here hope you guys have a great time as I did Kid-friendliness: Good enough environment for kids its not too loud Wheelchair accessibility: Can access anywhere in a wheelchair chair - 7/10/2023 

The food was excellent and the service was really good. Kid-friendliness: We had 3 children with us and they got exactly what they needed it wanted. Kid-friendliness: We had 3 children with us and they got exactly what they needed it wanted. - 5/12/2023 

I enjoy this place. I don't go often, since it is far enough away, but it's worth the stop if you're in the area. - 4/30/2023 

It doesn't look like much on the outside, but DAYUM it's gorgeous in the inside! Drinks were fantastic, food, and service all top notch. - 4/29/2023 

Nice family atmosphere. Good service. Food was hot and came out quickly!! - 4/29/2023 

Love this place! All the staff are always welcoming, you never have to wait for anything. Soon as you sit down you are given chips, dip and water. The food is excellent! Drinks are very well made! I would highly recommend this restaurant to all! - 4/04/2023 

This is my boyfriend's and I favorite spot to eat. The servers are all friendly and the food is fast and tastes great. Plus, their drinks are awesome, too. - 3/19/2023 

Service was great. Food was delicious with large portions. Kid-friendliness: They have a good kids menue selection. - 3/05/2023 

Omni the bartender makes some fantastic custom drinks. Pablo, you should put some of these on the menu. This restaurant and the one in Martinsville are the best for Mexican food. - 2/28/2023 

Nice atmosphere and great food. - 2/05/2023 

Great food. Great service - 1/19/2023 

Tried the seafood chim was great - 1/13/2023 

Fast service - 12/20/2022 

Great food and great service!! - 11/10/2022 

Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5 More - 10/28/2022 

Great food and great service!! Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5 … More - 10/23/2022 

Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5 More - 10/23/2022 

Food : 4/5 | Service : 4/5 | Atmosphere : 4/5 - 10/13/2022 

Great food and experience! - 8/24/2022 

I've been here multiple times & have always enjoyed my food. The restaurant is clean, staff are friendly, and service is quick! - 7/20/2022 

Excellent food and great service. We had a large group and they were great. - 7/20/2022 

Very lively music and great service. - 7/17/2022 

fast and good food 👍I really like it - 6/20/2022 

Good people, great guacamole, tastey food and cold margaritas. We always enjoy each experience at Herradura. And you cant go wrong with taco Tuesday! Def recommend. - 5/18/2022 

Great food and people. - 5/11/2022 

Recomiendo este lugar buen zason - 4/27/2022 

Very good food, great service! - 4/10/2022 

Good drinks and pretty good food. Only been there once, but will return. Lots of seating inside, bigger than it looks from the outside. Nice outdoor seating area out back as well. - 3/27/2022 

Highly recommend it. - 3/17/2022 

Yum! - 3/17/2022 

The food was tasty and the margaritas are really really Good. - 2/17/2022 

Very nice clean ...good crew of people!! - 1/29/2022 

Very good. Very hot. Giant beer. - 1/22/2022 

My husband loves this place. It has very kind staff and I felt very well taken care of. - 1/12/2022 

Good food, great prices. I tried the burrito herradura challenge, best deal for big appetites! The pictures in the menu don't do it justice. Note my hand in the pic below, I wear a XXL glove. - 12/12/2021 

Very busy restaurant, but excellent, quick service. The food was delicious. I had a burrito, which was very large, with rice and beans. A meal for 4 adults and 1 teenager was $60. - 12/12/2021 

Great food and service! Can't say enough good things about this place. Go check them out! - 12/12/2021 

Steak and shrimp fajitas was good, service was good...their house margaritas are nasty. - 12/12/2021 

The food is great and the staff is attentive! I haven't had a bad meal there so many good dishes - 10/12/2021 

Great service and they have great food! - 9/16/2021 

Delicious food and friendly staff. Worth the drive to Bargersville! - 9/12/2021 

Great food, good friendly service. Be careful if you have food allergies, my husband's meal had shrimp in it and was not supposed to. No issue for him but dangerous for me. - 8/12/2021 

Great place to eat very friendly people would eat there anytime. - 8/12/2021 

Foods was awesome as Usual.But, the flies were awful - 8/12/2021 

Best Mexican food in Bargersville! - 8/12/2021 

Delicious tacos and margaritas! - 8/12/2021 

Bar service great! - 8/12/2021 

Great Mexican food - 8/12/2021 

Delicious! We will be back the next time we are driving through. - 7/12/2021 

definitely the best margaritas and food in bargersville - 7/12/2021 

The food and service is fantastic! - 7/12/2021 

We always enjoy the delicious food and friendly servers. But best of all we appreciate the one server that found our credit card and returned it to us upon our next visit. Add integrity and honesty to their credit too. We would highly recommend a visit. Go hungry and leave full. - 6/16/2021 

Great margaritas. Excellent steak tacos! Friendly staff. Try the habenero sauce. Be sure to have a beer in hand first. Great daily lunch specials. You should go at least once! - 6/12/2021 

Great serive and great food. The staff was very friendly. I got the Steak Indiana and the fries were fire!!!! - 6/12/2021 

Close to home nice place. - 5/15/2021 

First time here and we will be back. Food was better than other local Mexican restaurants and prices were fair. Staff was attentive and dishes served fast. - 5/12/2021 

Buen lugar la comida es excelente todo lo que he comido en ese lugar me ha encantado se los recomiendo - 5/12/2021 

Great service, great food, and the BEST margaritas! Roberta is a mastermind when handcrafting them! - 5/12/2021 

Always good service and great food - 5/12/2021 

Good food, good service, clean - 5/12/2021 

Great Food and great staff make for a fun environment. - 4/18/2021 

Great food and friendly service. The portion sizes are just a little too big, but everything is well prepared and they are top shelf margaritas will knock you on your backside. The back porch is my favorite of all the eating spots. On a nice day, the rustic setting is perfect. - 4/17/2021 

I ordered the wet burrito and it was amazing. Took half of it home. Service was also very good. Will definitely go back. Sorry I didn't take more pictures. We sat outside and watched a beautiful sunset. - 4/17/2021 

Always an excellent experience here. The staff is kind and helpful, and management is incredible. Food is some of the best mexican anywhere close by, and prices are reasonable. I can't wait to come back! - 4/17/2021 

Good place too eat. Pricing is about average. They have good service. I wish the younger customers tonight weren't so loud tonight, but take that with a grain of salt. We will be going back next time. - 4/17/2021 

Wasn't busy. Quick service. Very good food - 4/17/2021 

Authentic and great! Friendly staff too. - 4/17/2021 

Great service and great food! - 4/17/2021 

We drove from Castleton to Bargersville because this place is that good! The food is always VERY good, authentic, and fresh. I love how the restaurant is divided up; the noise level is greatly reduced. The decor is bright and lively as a Mexican restaurant should be. - 4/12/2021 

The atmosphere was very comfortable then laid-back - 4/12/2021 

Excellent food and atmosphere - 4/12/2021 

Yum! - 4/12/2021 

Food is amazing, we love the skinny margaritas.. however, only a few know how to make them.. Pablo and Hester need to hold a training class for the skinny margaritas .. food and service , superb!! - 3/12/2021 

The people AND the food are both top notch. This is the best Mexican Cuisine I have ever had. - 3/12/2021 

Great food, large portions. - 3/12/2021 

Edit 2/23 - we've been here several times now, and the experience has been good each time!After being disappointed with the Mexican restaurants in Franklin, we decided to try this place. First impressions were good. The gentleman who seated us was super friendly. We received salsa nearly immediately, and the server wasn't far behind. She was on top of checking on us, and never had to ask for something. Food came out reasonably fast, and was flavorful. The carne asada was tender and tasted good. We'll definitely be back! I'd recommend them. - 2/12/2021 

Great food and friendly service. The portion sizes are just a little too big, but everything is well prepared and they are top shelf margaritas will knock you on your backside. The back porch is my favorite of all the eating spots. On a nice day, the rustic setting is perfect. - 2/12/2021 

I ordered the wet burrito and it was amazing. Took half of it home. Service was also very good. Will definitely go back. Sorry I didn't take more pictures. We sat outside and watched a beautiful sunset. - 2/12/2021 

Always an excellent experience here. The staff is kind and helpful, and management is incredible. Food is some of the best mexican anywhere close by, and prices are reasonable. I can't wait to come back! - 2/12/2021 

Good place too eat. Pricing is about average. They have good service. I wish the younger customers tonight weren't so loud tonight, but take that with a grain of salt. We will be going back next time. - 2/12/2021 

These folks are always warm when you arrive, take very good care of you & have awesome salsa. And I'm a picky salsa eater! They were amazing during the COVID shut down with their take out. - 2/12/2021 

Cleanest friendlest staff and restaurant youll find. Love that it has the small town feel . great Location. Huge portions and super affordable! - 2/12/2021 

We have been going here for awhile Ivin is the Best Ever .We are soo glad He is back .Wasn't the same without him - 2/12/2021 

Really great food and service was polite. Can not beat the 4.99 lunch deals. I've been back about 3 times now - 2/12/2021 

Everything I've ordered has been solid. Definitely worth the trip down to bargersville for dinner - 2/12/2021 

Healthy portions sizes of really good authentic food when dinning in. Definitely a spot to stop. - 2/12/2021 

First visit. Good was fresh and delicious. Waiter friendly. Reasonable prices. - 2/12/2021 

Was really good place to eat. Stopped here for lunch on our way back home. - 2/12/2021 

4th trip here. This is excellent Mexican food. Service is also great. - 2/12/2021 

Food is always good and hot and a good price Margaritas are good too - 2/12/2021 

Mushroom quesadilla was delicious! Great fast & friendly service! - 2/12/2021 

Great food, great service. Can't say enough about the place. - 2/12/2021 

Wasn't busy. Quick service. Very good food - 2/12/2021 

They got the Hot Food 2 our table quickly - 2/12/2021 

Authentic and great! Friendly staff too. - 2/12/2021 

The steak tacos and meat is awesome! - 2/12/2021 

Waiter was awesome! Great prices! - 2/12/2021 

Amazing food and big portions! - 2/12/2021 

Great service and great food! - 2/12/2021 

Favorite Mexican restaurant. - 2/12/2021 

Excellent food and service - 2/12/2021 

Friendly staff, good food - 2/12/2021 

Good food good service - 2/12/2021 

Best Mexican around! - 2/12/2021 

Had a great time... good food and service. - 10/31/2020 

This is without a doubt the BEST Mexican food I have ever had at a restaurant. My husband agrees. Although a little bit of a drive from our house, we will definitely be back. So worth the drive. The salsa was on point. Lots of cheese. Cheese sauce was thick and oh so good. My seafood enchiladas were stuffed with seafood. My husband had the phillysteak burrito and it was full of steak plus had steak on top! If you have not tried it, you are missing out! - 10/18/2020 

Ask for the fat boy special!! 5-STARS - 8/15/2020 

Thee most BEST Mexican restaurant EVER! The food, service and atomphere are TRULY amazing! I DO NOT understand some of these bad reviews, because La Herradua II changed ownership. This resturant has in fact improved SO much more with the new owners! You are greeted immediately with a smile, kind words and seated. In fact the staff is SO friendly that they treat you like family. Jerrod is the BEST waiter ever and he ALWAYS remembers our names and what we like to drink. We LOVE you Jerrod! Your food comes out as pretty as a food magazine picture and tastes WONDERFUL! I HIGHLY recommend this AMAZING restaurant and WISH I could give it a 100 stars! - 5/25/2020 

The food is absolutely amazing! Would have given 5 stars but the waiter kept forgetting about us and we had to keep flagging him down. Wasn't that busy in the restaurant he was socializing. Better waiter would have got a 5 star review. Food is fantastic though! Definitely going back, for sure! - 5/25/2020 

Eddie is great. Get the tomatillo salsa, best ever and done right with chipotle peppers, cilantro, onions, etc. Mezcal is the best hidden secret at the bar, love the Smokey, leathery taste! - 5/25/2020 

Wonderful dinner - outstanding service! Chicken fajitas, Chile relleno combo, fajita grande - all were special! - 5/25/2020 

Really great food and service was polite. Can not beat the 4.99 lunch deals. I've been back about 3 times now - 5/25/2020 

Was our first time there the food was excellent and the service was great to the definitely go back - 5/25/2020 

Food was good, but nothing out of the ordinary. Disappointed they do not heat their chips. - 5/25/2020 

Has good food, bit has lost some of its atmosphere after it changed owners. - 5/25/2020 

Good food, great people, love coming here. Service is fast and correct. - 5/25/2020 

Enjoyed the jalepeno cucumber margaritas! You have to try at least one! - 5/25/2020 

Always very good and their Wet Burrito is FANTASTIC! - 5/25/2020 

The food and the service were both great!!! - 5/25/2020 

Good food friendly service. Ssk for Jerry. - 5/25/2020 

Such good food! Definitely going back! - 5/25/2020 

Muy bien todo la comida y la atención - 5/25/2020 

Prettiest hostess I've ever seen 🙂 - 5/25/2020 

Really needs a website and menu, - 5/25/2020 

Food and service were great!!! - 5/25/2020 

Favorite Mexican restaurant. - 5/25/2020 

This place is really good - 5/25/2020 

Friendly staff, good food - 5/25/2020 

Beautiful view and good - 5/25/2020 

Good food and service - 5/25/2020 

Plenty of food - 5/25/2020 

Great food 👌 - 5/25/2020 

Good food. - 5/25/2020 

Loved it. - 5/25/2020 

After being disappointed with the Mexican restaurants in Franklin, we decided to try this place. First impressions were good. The gentleman who seated us was super friendly. We received salsa nearly immediately, and the server wasn't far behind. She was on top of checking on us, and never had to ask for something. Food came out reasonably fast, and was flavorful. The carne asada was tender and tasted good. We'll definitely be back! I'd recommend them. - 3/14/2020 

Thee most BEST Mexican restaurant EVER! The food, service and atomphere are TRULY amazing! I DO NOT understand some of these bad reviews, because La Herradua II changed ownership. This resturant has in fact improved SO much more with the new owners! You are greeted immediately with a smile, kind words and seated. In fact the staff is SO friendly that they treat you like family. Jerrod is the BEST waiter ever and he ALWAYS remembers our names and what we like to drink. We LOVE you Jerrod! Your food comes out as pretty as a food magazine picture and tastes WONDERFUL! I HIGHLY recommend this AMAZING restaurant and WISH I could give it a 100 stars! - 2/12/2020 

Owner nice wants to please customer 's , & jackie good server takes care of you.Good meal& 2 🌮 tacos on there special mayo day!! Happy with service @ 2:00pm ...only thing wish alittle pricey $$$ thought feitias should have been a little cheaper meals??!! Other than that heard he owns 4 more Restraunt s Greenwood, Bargersville, Morgan twn, Martinsville, Franklin?? As new in Bargersville hope prices go alittle lower& good specials& Margaritas & $5.00..... - 2/12/2020 

The owners of La Herradura in Martinsville IN have recently acquired this restaurant in Bargersville IN and are bringing their exceptional quality and fantastic food to this new location. La Herradura II is just as fantastic as it's predecessor. The food was fabulous and the service was even better. Great work ethic and amazing food. If you're traveling down SR 135 through Bargersville, stop by and give La Herradura II a try. You won't be disappointed! - 2/12/2020 

The new owners have really taken this place over. The food is incredible and the overall atmosphere has completely changed with update decor! Eddie and Jarrod are amazing and make the overall experience wonderful with great company . The new menu is huge with the food being fresh and extremely authentic! I drive all the way from Indianapolis to eat here because its worth it! - 2/12/2020 

New owners, and very happy! I was tired of the old menu and everything tasted the same. The new owners came in, added their own new decor, made it an authentic Mexican atmosphere WITH the same amazing margaritas they had before! Some old staff, some new, same family atmosphere! I like this place more now than before. Must check out!!! - 2/12/2020 

The food is absolutely amazing! Would have given 5 stars but the waiter kept forgetting about us and we had to keep flagging him down. Wasn't that busy in the restaurant he was socializing. Better waiter would have got a 5 star review. Food is fantastic though! Definitely going back, for sure! - 2/12/2020 

Eddie is great. Get the tomatillo salsa, best ever and done right with chipotle peppers, cilantro, onions, etc. Mezcal is the best hidden secret at the bar, love the Smokey, leathery taste! - 2/12/2020 

Wonderful dinner - outstanding service! Chicken fajitas, Chile relleno combo, fajita grande - all were special! - 2/12/2020 

Was our first time there the food was excellent and the service was great to the definitely go back - 2/12/2020 

Food was good, but nothing out of the ordinary. Disappointed they do not heat their chips. - 2/12/2020 

Food was delicious, new decor is awesome and servers continue to be gracious and helpful! - 2/12/2020 

Has good food, bit has lost some of its atmosphere after it changed owners. - 2/12/2020 

Good food, great people, love coming here. Service is fast and correct. - 2/12/2020 

Enjoyed the jalepeno cucumber margaritas! You have to try at least one! - 2/12/2020 

Always very good and their Wet Burrito is FANTASTIC! - 2/12/2020 

Great food, huge servings , friendly atmosphere - 2/12/2020 

Nice place great food and easy on the wallet - 2/12/2020 

The food and the service were both great!!! - 2/12/2020 

Good food friendly service. Ssk for Jerry. - 2/12/2020 

Such good food! Definitely going back! - 2/12/2020 

Muy bien todo la comida y la atención - 2/12/2020 

Prettiest hostess I've ever seen 🙂 - 2/12/2020 

Really needs a website and menu, - 2/12/2020 

Food and service were great!!! - 2/12/2020 

This place is really good - 2/12/2020 

Beautiful view and good - 2/12/2020 

Good food and service - 2/12/2020 

Plenty of food - 2/12/2020 

Great food 👌 - 2/12/2020 

Good food. - 2/12/2020 

Loved it. - 2/12/2020 

Owner nice wants to please customer 's , & jackie good server takes care of you.Good meal& 2 🌮 tacos on there special mayo day!! Happy with service @ 2:00pm ...only thing wish alittle pricey $$$ thought feitias should have been a little cheaper meals??!! Other than that heard he owns 4 more Restraunt s Greenwood, Bargersville, Morgan twn, Martinsville, Franklin?? As new in Bargersville hope prices go alittle lower& good specials& Margaritas & $5.00..... - 5/25/2019 

The owners of La Herradura in Martinsville IN have recently acquired this restaurant in Bargersville IN and are bringing their exceptional quality and fantastic food to this new location. La Herradura II is just as fantastic as it's predecessor. The food was fabulous and the service was even better. Great work ethic and amazing food. If you're traveling down SR 135 through Bargersville, stop by and give La Herradura II a try. You won't be disappointed! - 5/25/2019 

The new owners have really taken this place over. The food is incredible and the overall atmosphere has completely changed with update decor! Eddie and Jarrod are amazing and make the overall experience wonderful with great company . The new menu is huge with the food being fresh and extremely authentic! I drive all the way from Indianapolis to eat here because its worth it! - 5/25/2019 

New owners, and very happy! I was tired of the old menu and everything tasted the same. The new owners came in, added their own new decor, made it an authentic Mexican atmosphere WITH the same amazing margaritas they had before! Some old staff, some new, same family atmosphere! I like this place more now than before. Must check out!!! - 5/25/2019 

Food was delicious, new decor is awesome and servers continue to be gracious and helpful! - 5/25/2019 

Great food, huge servings , friendly atmosphere - 5/25/2019 

Nice place great food and easy on the wallet - 5/25/2019